Most agency origin stories start with a decision. The Husman Brothers’ story starts with two firings, a scam house, a cancer diagnosis, and an employer whose name you can now Google in connection with one of the largest illegal dumping disasters in North Texas history.
Justin and Aaron Husman are the co-founders of Phoenix Insurance — a niche personal lines agency based in the Dallas-Fort Worth area that has been operating for sixteen years. They specialize in standard and preferred personal lines, collector vehicles, boats, and motorcycles. They are not a soup kitchen, and they’ll explain exactly what they mean by that.
I sat down with both brothers for Agency Blueprint and came away with one of the most unfiltered founder conversations I’ve had on this show. These two have seen some things — and what they built on the other side of all of it is worth paying attention to.
A Father Who Carried the Family Up the Mountain
Before there was Phoenix Insurance, there was their dad.
He had Justin as a teenager, straight out of high school. He was working four jobs while Justin was still in elementary school. He moved to new cities — alone, without his family — multiple times to take promotions that would let the rest of them catch up later. He got his master’s degree the same year his youngest son Aaron graduated high school and the same year Justin got out of the Navy.
“His first year in Dallas he made five thousand dollars, and he just thought if he could make ten, the family would be set.”
From the laundry department at Presbyterian Hospital in Dallas, he built a career that eventually led to director-level administration. No excuses. No shortcuts. Just the next thing, and the thing after that.
When you hear Justin and Aaron talk about their own story — the chaos, the bad employers, the hard years — that foundation is the whole reason they never stopped moving.
The Scam House MBA
Justin took a job out of high school with a friend selling oil well investments. If you’ve seen the movie Boiler Room, he says, that’s basically what it was — except the oil wells mysteriously never seemed to hit.
Aaron, fresh out of college with a degree and no good job leads, was sent there by his father. The logic was simple: it was a paycheck.
“I got fired because I mouthed off to the boss and Aaron was fired because he was my brother.”
That was Boss Number One. He went to jail.
They landed in insurance next — hired without an interview by a man who turned out to be equally questionable. He ran a real agency with real carriers, real policies, real coverage. There was just no structure, no training, no manual. Here are the logins. Go figure it out.
They stayed for six years. They figured it out.
“It taught us we could run an agency. We understood what went into it — the relationship with carriers, the commissions, how the statements come through, how to service all the policies.”
Boss Number Two also went to prison. He is now, Aaron notes, involved in one of the largest environmental disasters in North Texas history for illegal dumping. You can Google “illegal dumping Trinity River.” That was their old guy.
They left before any of that became their problem. And they took everything they’d learned — good and bad — with them.
Three Desks, One Printer, and a Cardstock Sign
When they walked out of that agency for the last time, they went straight to IKEA.
They needed desks. They bought three — not two. The third desk was for the employee they intended to hire, because that was the mindset from day one. They bought three computers for the same reason. They found a Brother MFC 8890 printer that they still use today, sixteen years later, depreciated down to almost nothing.
Justin printed “Phoenix Insurance World Headquarters” on a piece of cardstock and taped it to the door of Aaron’s wife’s condo. That was their first office.
Within the first few months: Justin’s paid-off Jeep got repossessed. A front tooth cap he’d had since a childhood car accident finally gave out. The homeowners association threatened to tow Justin’s motorcycle from the parking lot. Carriers wouldn’t appoint them because they were operating out of a residential address.
Two years in, Aaron got cancer. His daughter was born a few months later.
“I was learning about marriage and business partnership at the same time. I was having kids and learning about raising employees at the same time.”
None of it stopped them. Not because they were fearless — but because they had already decided. The third desk was already there.
Agency or Soup Kitchen?
Sixteen years and a lot of hard lessons later, the Husman Brothers are clear about who Phoenix Insurance is built to serve — and equally clear about who it isn’t.
Justin put it in a way that’s stayed with me since the conversation.
“How much are we forgetting that we’re running a business versus running a soup kitchen?”
It’s a real question. Insurance people are, by nature, helpers. Someone calls with a problem; the instinct is to solve it. But when every call turns into a project, and every project is for a client who doesn’t fit your model, the agency that could have been excellent at one thing becomes mediocre at everything.
Aaron frames it through the hedgehog concept — Jim Collins’s framework about finding the one thing you can be the best in the world at and going deep.
“That’s your hedgehog concept. And really, that’s what can move the needle and give you the traction that everybody in theory is seeking.”
Phoenix Insurance writes personal lines for preferred risks — people with nice homes, collector cars, boats, motorcycles. They are very good at it. When a contractor calls because he heard they’re a great insurance agency and he needs a general liability policy, they don’t contort themselves to write a policy they weren’t built for. They send him somewhere better suited. That’s not coldness. That’s focus.
“There is enough good business. I don’t want to have to stress about it and fight so hard.”
The Regret Worth Naming
Justin made one of the more honest admissions I’ve heard on this show. They spent five years at that chaotic agency before leaving to start their own. Looking back, he thinks it should have been three.
“We spent more time thinking and worrying about what might happen rather than putting into action what could happen. If there is any regret, it’s that we spent five years there versus three.”
The business plan was real. The preparation was real. But at some point, planning becomes a way of avoiding the thing you’re afraid to do. You can dress fear up in spreadsheets and call it due diligence, but it’s still fear.
Their closing advice to anyone sitting on the same fence right now was delivered in five words.
“You’ll never get it perfect. Just get started.”
You can connect with Aaron on LinkedIn, Justin on LinkedIn, and explore what they’ve built at Phoenix Insurance.
At ia Blueprint, we work with agency owners who are ready to stop doing everything themselves and start building the focused, well-run agency they set out to create. If you’re still wearing all the hats and wondering when it’s going to feel like a real business, book a discovery call. Let’s talk about what’s next.